Niche Blogging: Limit Visitor Choices?

Here’s a little experiment that I’ve been trying on some niche blogs I recently created. The idea is to narrow visitor choice on the page down to the point that an Adsense block or an affiliate offer are the most logical exit points aside from the back button. In this article I’ll go over how I’m setting this up and some of the reasoning behind it.

Content and Theme

Niche Blogging: Limit Visitor Choices?I’ve used very narrowly written content that is built around a handful of targeted keywords and related long tail terms. In many cases, the articles essentially echo each other although they’re written where they would not trigger any duplicate filtering. I’ve also varied the length between about 300 and 1000 words. They’re also linked to each other with the goal of obtaining a dual search results entry.

For a theme, I’m trying out a couple very minimalist themes, including a new, very minimalist, one column theme called Stripped. I make extensive modification to the themes. I removed almost all of the typical navigational widgets you would see in on a typical blog such as a RSS feed, categories, recent posts, date archive and so forth. I’ve left a few standard items, like links to the home page, about page, and search at the bottom of the page. I’ve also removed date/time from the posts.

But Everybody Likes a Choice, Don’t They?

Confused By ChoicesThe conventional blogging wisdom is that it is good to provide a blog visitor with a lot of navigational choices. I even encourage this in my Free Blog Reviews. The idea behind it is the goal of keeping the visitor on your site. But, is that the best strategy for a niche blog?

Perhaps it isn’t.

Your average blog usually has dozens of choices as to where to go next. Just look on this page for an example. There are probably close to 100 internal and external links on this page. While this isn’t bad when you want someone browsing around your site it can dilute a marketing message. In fact, having a lot of options can become counterproductive to the goals of a niche blog.

Some marketing research has found that giving too much choice, whether it’s advertising links on a web page or varieties of toothpaste, actually leads people away from taking risks, like clicking on an ad or buying a new product. Having a lot of choices can force people to narrow their view, become defensive and increase their banner blindness. It can lead to snap judgments, such a clicking the back button, just to avoid the stress of dealing with a large number of confusing options.

A Bird in the Hand

A happy shopperMarketing psychologists have also noted another trend in this area. When it comes time to choose, if people already have established a preference they will not be as stressed by a reasonable number of choices. Because their mind is already partially made up, they’ll be looking for choices that reinforce their line of thinking. This is why Adsense works well on a highly optimized niche blog post but usually does poorly on a general or social oriented blog post.

If your advertising block completes the loop in the mind of the visitor the odds of them clicking the ad greatly increase. This is why search traffic tends to convert well. The searcher is trying to find a way to complete the loop. To be successful, your niche blog has to offer them an easy and comfortable way to do this.

You also have to remember that a lot of advertising revolves around validating the emotional feelings of the customer. Few people really think about advertising logically and, not surprisingly, these people who think on the logical side tend to be more unhappy and even depressed as compared to the general population. Thus, if you’re trying to think logically, as in “A good blog must have a prominent RSS feed widget”, you may miss the point.

What are your thoughts on this? Are you making your niche blogs look like regular old blogs? Have you tried a minimalist approach? Leave a comment and let me know what you think about this idea.


RSS feed | Trackback URI


Comment by Grizzly
2008-02-07 17:00:42

Thanks Frank - great advice. Geez, you actually did research on this, what a refreshing change from all the regurgitations posted elsewhere. I may have to start watching the serp’s in case you creep up on me! lol.

Comment by jfc
2008-02-07 17:28:44

Hi Griz,

Ha! I don’t think that will happen.

I’m pleased with the results I’m seeing so far from the new niche blogs I’ve created using this technique though. Your double indexing trick has worked quite well. Now I just need to learn to ramble better. :)

Comment by Grizzly
2008-02-08 07:47:42

Actually I think you ramble quite well - perfect serp food. You’re a very good writer Frank, don’t change a thing.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by Aaron Anderson
2008-02-07 18:11:07

I love the minimalist approach. I have my blog setup so that I have a sidebar on the homepage but when you click through to one of the articles it disappears. But I do have a few links for navigational purposes.

People think they like options but in most cases they really don’t. Given to many they end up doing nothing at all. Where if you would have only given then one option they would be more likely to do it.

Comment by jfc
2008-02-07 20:26:17

Hi Aaron,

I’ve seen your blog a few times on EntreCard dropping runs as well as from Blogging Zoom entries. I think it works well since you’re going for a minimalist approach. It’s always good to see a different approach rather than the “same old, same old”

Comment by Saedel
2008-02-08 19:09:03

Hi Frank,

Your post is convincing, and to be perfectly honest I haven’t thought of a niche blog using a minimalist approach, despite being minimalist myself.

I will try another niche using this method.

By the way, excellent post, as always. Interesting and engaging; I read everything from top to bottom straight.


2008-02-10 04:24:07

[…] Niche Blogging: Limit Visitor Choices? - by Frank Carr, saying, “Here’s a little experiment that I’ve been trying on some niche […]

Comment by RT Cunningham
2008-02-10 08:59:19

I think your ideas are spot on, Frank. In fact, that’s the route I intend to go when I start on niche blogs (April/May).

Comment by jfc
2008-02-10 20:45:34

Hi RT,

I hope everything is going well for you right now.

Hopefully I’ll have some more performance data in a few months to see how different approaches are working.

Comment by YC
2008-02-10 09:25:58

Hi Frank, I never really thought about it but you’re spot on about this. When I think about it, my better performing blogs ad-wise have very limited choices in terms of things to click through once they have visited, and the choices are usually restricted to ads. Great writeup.

Comment by jfc
2008-02-10 20:52:51

Hi Y.S.,

I think part of it is that it can’t look like your typical “Made for Adsense” site, with ad blocks overwhelming the content and scrapped or Markoved content. The content has to be good but lightweight reading that leaves them hungry for more info. The more you can make the site look like a reference site, the better.

Comment by Gotafish
2008-02-18 16:51:22

Very Interesting, From past experience in retail marketing the general rule was to only offer the customer two choices of products to purchase, three at the most. When a consumer is confronted with to many choices they tend to get frustrated and often talk themselves out of the purchase completely. I dont see why this principal shouldn’t apply to the internet surfer as well.

2008-09-22 09:36:04

Frank is there none of my quesionts that you haven’t already blogged on? Thanks

Name (required)
E-mail (required - never shown publicly)
A Link To Your Site
Your Comment (smaller size | larger size)
You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong> in your comment. Comments with links are automatically moderated but are normally allowed after review. New commentators are automatically moderated. You may use anchored text in your signature link as long as your comment is meaningful and on topic. Signature links inside of the comment body are not allowed.


Some graphics Copyright 2005 Riverdeep Interactive Learning Limited, and its licensors. All rights reserved
Some graphics Copyright 2005 Cosmi Corporation, and its licensors. All rights reserved.
All graphics are intended for viewing purposes only.

Directory of General Blogs Personal blogs Top Blogs Marketing SEO blogs Webfeed (RSS/ATOM/RDF) registered at BRDTracker blog directory